Sustainable apparel and accessories are super popular right now. People are making a conscious decision to shop secondhand or with companies who are making significant sustainable manufacturing.
The two companies we’re comparing today are big players in the sustainable shoe market; VIVAIA and Rothy’s.
VIVAIA Versus Rothy’s: Which is the Better Sustainable Shoe
We’ll list the differences between each brand so that you can make the decision on which shoe brand is better for you.
| Rothy’s | VIVAIA | |
|---|---|---|
| Quality | Durable | Much finer knit and durable |
| Price | More Expensive
Starts are $125 |
Cheaper than Rothy’s
Starts at $78 and can range up to $198 |
| Color and Pattern Selection | Shoes are offered in many colors and patterns. | Shoes are offered in many colors and patterns. |
| Comfortability | Comfortable and flexible knit fabric.
Can be rough on feet that require cushion or arch support. No arch or heel support. |
Comfortable and flexible knit fabric.
Has heel and arch support built into the shoe liner. Certain styles have chunky soles which are very plush and comfortable. |
| Sizing | Sizing can be inconsistent.
Runs small – We recommend sizing up in certain styles. |
Initially, VIVAIA shoes ran big. After some redesigning and taking feedback, their shoes now run true to size (TTS). |
| Discounts | Get 20% off your first order with this link. | Get 18% off all orders with this link or code SCHIMIGGY. |
| Style Selection | Plenty of styles to choose from, but none of the styles offer heels. | More styles to choose from than Rothy’s. They have many styles which have heels. |
| Made in | China | China |
| Packaging | Sustainable packaging | Sustainable until received by US shipping partner who wraps their products in bubble wrap and plastic. |
What’s the Verdict?
Ultimately, we decided we love both our Rothy’s and VIVAIA shoes.
Rothy’s are great because their packaging is more sustainable than VIVAIA’s and their shoes have more structure due to the knitting pattern.
On the other hand, we find VIVAIA shoes to be much more comfortable because they’re made with a finer knit pattern and they’re just as durable as Rothy’s shoes. They also come in more silhouettes and even offer shoes with heels. We also love their boot styles.
Read all of our Rothy’s reviews here.
And read all of our VIVAIA reviews here.
Don’t forget to use our links to save towards your first pair of sustainable women’s shoes.
VIVAIA Photos
Thank you for visiting today! If you found this encouraging or informative, please connect with us on Instagram or TikTok. Sign up for our monthly newsletter for updates and more. We promise we won't spam you! Feel free to unsubscribe anytime. If you're a brand and want to work with us, please visit this page to get in touch.
Shannon
Tuesday 13th of December 2022
Just once, as a female who wears a s 12 shoe, I'd like to be included in someone's demographic. Its 2022, the idea that a female may have large feet is not a wild concept. The explosion of openly trans women alone should have companies increasing their size catalog. Think about it please.
Kim
Sunday 9th of October 2022
Where did you get the red/orange sandals in the photo above?
Schimiggy
Sunday 22nd of January 2023
They are from VIVAIA! :D
Marci
Saturday 7th of August 2021
Maybe TMI, but…. I don’t have many pairs of shoes, and I walk a lot, so I put my shoes to the test. My Rothy’s look good after all the abuse I put them through, but they do start to smell after awhile, which washing, etc. does not cure. Do you have any knowledge on if Vivaias would do better in the odor area?
Schimiggy
Tuesday 31st of August 2021
I actually have no clue! My feet don't really sweat. I will ask my Vivaia group if they have any hacks and let you know. You can also join and ask other members if you're comfortable with that.